We introduce lattice gauge theories which describe three-dimensional, gapped quantum phases exhibiting the phenomenology of both conventional three-dimensional topological orders and fracton orders, starting from a finite group , a choice of an Abelian normal subgroup , and a choice of foliation structure. These hybrid fracton orders, examples of which were introduced in a previous paper [Tantivasadakarn et al., Phys. Rev. B 103, 245136 (2021)], can also host immobile, pointlike excitations that are non-Abelian, and therefore give rise to a protected degeneracy. We construct solvable lattice models for these orders which interpolate between a conventional, three-dimensional gauge theory and a pure fracton order, by varying the choice of normal subgroup . We demonstrate that certain universal data of the topological excitations and their mobilities are directly related to the choice of and , and also present complementary perspectives on these orders: certain orders may be obtained by gauging a global symmetry which enriches a particular fracton order, by either fractionalizing on or permuting the excitations with restricted mobility, while certain hybrid orders can be obtained by condensing excitations in a stack of initially decoupled, two-dimensional topological orders.