- Featured in Physics
- Open Access
Optimality Pressures toward Lateralization of Complex Brain Functions
Phys. Rev. X 13, 031028 – Published 13 September, 2023
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevX.13.031028
Abstract
Most animal brains present two mirror-symmetric sides, but closer inspection reveals a range of asymmetries (in shape and function) that seem more salient in more cognitively complex species. Sustaining symmetric, redundant neural circuitry has associated metabolic costs, but it might aid in implementing computations within noisy environments or with faulty pieces. It has been suggested that the complexity of a computational task might play a role in breaking bilaterally symmetric circuits into fully lateralized ones; however, a rigorous, mathematically grounded theory of how this mechanism might work is missing. Here, we provide such a mathematical framework, starting with the simplest assumptions but extending our results to a comprehensive range of biologically relevant scenarios. We show mathematically that only fully lateralized or bilateral solutions are relevant within our framework (dismissing configurations in which circuits are only partially engaged). We provide maps that show when each configuration is preferred depending on costs, fitness contributed, circuit reliability, and task complexity. We discuss evolutionary paths leading from bilateral to lateralized configurations and other possible outcomes. The implications of these results for evolution, development, and rehabilitation of damaged or aging brains is discussed. Our work constitutes a limit case that should constrain and underlie similar mappings when other aspects (besides task complexity and circuit reliability) are considered.
Physics Subject Headings (PhySH)
synopsis
Brain Asymmetry Driven by Task Complexity
A mathematical model shows how increased intricacy of cognitive tasks can break the mirror symmetry of the brain’s neural network.
See more in Physics
Popular Summary
The human brain is mirror symmetric: Both hemispheres are similar but flipped sideways. Because of this, most neural circuitry comes in couples. There are, for example, two motor cortices, one in each side. This duplicity can be useful for controlling body parts that are mirror symmetric too, such as hands and legs. But it can also be redundant—we need to control only one language system with no obvious symmetries. Nevertheless, redundant circuits can help improve computing accuracy or provide replacements if one unit gets damaged. It has been hypothesized that increased cognitive complexity can cause the loss of bilateral symmetry, leading to specialized circuits in one side only. Here, we prove this to be true using a rigorous mathematical framework.
We lay out a minimal mathematical model to map optimal configurations (bilateral, fully lateralized, or somewhere in between) of computing neural units as a function of their running costs, fitness gain, reliability, and complexity of the task at hand. Our analysis of this model shows that increasing complexity can indeed cause the breakup of mirror symmetry in computing circuits. We also prove that complexity can operate in the opposite direction, favoring the recovery of lost duplicity. The different outcomes could be obtained in real neural systems as Darwinian evolution proceeds, or as a brain develops and ages. We chart when to expect each scenario depending on the cost and reliability of neural units and given the complexity of a cognitive task and the fitness that it contributes.
Our findings can help explain real neuroscientific scenarios, such as how a brain responds to damage or aging as well as how cognitively demanding tasks shape brain architecture.
Article Text
References (72)
- A. M. Galaburda, M. LeMay, T. L. Kemper, and N. Geschwind, Right-Left Asymmetrics in the Brain, Science 199, 852 (1978).
- A. W. Toga and P. M. Thompson, Mapping Brain Asymmetry, Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 4, 37 (2003).
- K. Hugdahl, Symmetry and Asymmetry in the Human Brain, Eur. Rev. 13, 119 (2005).
- P. Y. Hervé, L. Zago, L. Petit, B. Mazoyer, and N. Tzourio-Mazoyer, Revisiting Human Hemispheric Specialization with Neuroimaging, Trends Cognit. Sci. 17, 69 (2013).
- X. Z. Kong, S. R. Mathias, T. Guadalupe, D. C. Glahn, B. Franke, F. Crivello, N. Tzourio-Mazoyer, S. E. Fisher, P. M. Thompson, and C. Francks (ENIGMA Laterality Working Group), Mapping Cortical Brain Asymmetry in 17,141 Healthy Individuals Worldwide via the ENIGMA Consortium, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 115, E5154 (2018).
- X. Z. Kong, M. C. Postema, T. Guadalupe, C. de Kovel, P. S. Boedhoe, M. Hoogman, S. R. Mathias, D. Van Rooij, D. Schijven, D. C. Glahn, and S. E. Medland, Mapping Brain Asymmetry in Health and Disease through the ENIGMA Consortium, Hum. Brain Mapp. 43, 167 (2020).
- L. F. Seoane, Fate of Duplicated Neural Structures, Entropy 22, 928 (2020).
- N. Geschwind, Language and the Brain, Sci. Am. 226, 76 (1972).
- M. Catani, D. K. Jones, and D. H. Ffytche, Perisylvian Language Networks of the Human Brain, Ann. Neurol. 57, 8 (2005).
- E. Fedorenko and N. Kanwisher, Neuroimaging of Language: Why Hasn’t a Clearer Picture Emerged?, Lang. Linguist. 3, 839 (2009).
- E. Fedorenko, A. Nieto-Castanon, and N. Kanwisher, Lexical and Syntactic Representations in the Brain: An fMRI Investigation with Multi-Voxel Pattern Analyses, Neuropsychologia 50, 499 (2012).
- E. Fedorenko and S. L. Thompson-Schill, Reworking the Language Network, Trends Cognit. Sci. 18, 120 (2014).
- I. Blank, Z. Balewski, K. Mahowald, and E. Fedorenko, Syntactic Processing Is Distributed Across the Language System, NeuroImage 127, 307 (2016).
- R. C. Berwick and N. Chomsky, Why Only Us: Language and Evolution (MIT Press, Cambridge, USA, 2016).
- S. Malik-Moraleda, D. Ayyash, J. Gallée, J. Affourtit, M. Hoffmann, Z. Minerof, O. Jouravlev, and E. Fedorenko, An Investigation Across 45 Languages and 12 Language Families Reveals a Universal Language Network, Nat. Neurosci. 25, 1014 (2022).
- H. D. Brown and S. M. Kosslyn, Hemispheric Differences in Visual Object Processing: Structural versus Allocation Theories, in Brain Asymmetry, edited by R. J. Davidson and K. Hugdahl (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1995), pp. 77–97.
- J. B. Hellige, Hemispheric Asymmetry for Components of Visual Information Processing, in Brain Asymmetry, edited by R. J. Davidson and K. Hugdahl (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1995), pp. 99–121.
- A. M. Galaburda, Anatomic Basis of Cerebral Dominance, in Brain Asymmetry, edited by R. J. Davidson and K. Hugdahl (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1995), pp. 51–73.
- L. J. Rogers, P. Zucca, and G. Vallortigara, Advantages of Having a Lateralized Brain, Proc. R. Soc. B 271, S420 (2004).
- M. E. Halpern, O. Güntürkün, W. D. Hopkins, and L. J. Rogers, Lateralization of the Vertebrate Brain: Taking the Side of Model Systems, J. Neurosci. 25, 10351 (2005).
- L. J. Rogers, Cognitive and Social Advantages of a Lateralised Brain, in Behavioral and Morphological Asymmetries in Vertebrates, edited by Y. B. Malashichev and A. Wallace Deckel (Landes Bioscience, Georgetown, 2006), pp. 129–139, https://tinyurl.com/mvpdev85.
- A. Harrington, Unfinished Business: Models of Laterality in the Nineteenth Century, in Brain Asymmetry, edited by R. J. Davidson and K. Hugdahl (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1995), pp. 3–27.
- M. C. Corballis, The Evolution and Genetics of Cerebral Asymmetry, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B 364, 867 (2009).
- P. F. MacNeilage, L. J. Rogers, and G. Vallortigara, Evolutionary Origins of Your Right and Left Brain, Sci. Am. 301, 60 (2009).
- A. Pascual, K. L. Huang, J. Neveu, and T. Préat, Brain Asymmetry and Long-Term Memory, Nature (London) 427, 605 (2004).
- G. Vallortigara, L. J. Rogers, and A. Bisazza, Possible Evolutionary Origins of Cognitive Brain Lateralization, Brain Res. Rev. 30, 164 (1999).
- J. L. Ringo, R. W. Doty, S. Demeter, and P. Y. Simard, Time Is of the Essence: A Conjecture that Hemispheric Specialization Arises from Interhemispheric Conduction Delay, Cereb. Cortex 4, 331 (1994).
- M. C. Corballis, The Evolution of Lateralized Brain Circuits, Front. Psychol. 8, 1021 (2017).
- A. Kolchinsky and D. H. Wolpert, Thermodynamic Costs of Turing Machines, Phys. Rev. Res. 2, 033312 (2020).
- D. H. Wolpert and A. Kolchinsky, Thermodynamics of Computing with Circuits, New J. Phys. 22, 063047 (2020).
- A. Kolchinsky and D. H. Wolpert, Work, Entropy Production, and Thermodynamics of Information under Protocol Constraints, Phys. Rev. X 11, 041024 (2021).
- J. von Neumann, Probabilistic Logics and the Synthesis of Reliable Organisms from Unreliable Components, Automata Studies 34, 43 (1956).
- E. F. Moore and C. E. Shannon, Reliable Circuits Using Less Reliable Relays, J. Franklin Inst. 262, 191 (1956).
- S. Winograd and J. D. Cowan, Reliable Computation in the Presence of Noise (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1963).
- J. Liang, S. J. Wang, and C. Zhou, Less Is More: Wiring-Economical Modular Networks Support Self-Sustained Firing-Economical Neural Avalanches for Efficient Processing, Natl. Sci. Rev. 9, nwab102 (2022).
- G. M. Edelman, Neural Darwinism: The Theory of Neuronal Group Selection (Basic Books, New York, 1987).
- A. Ollé-Vila, L. F. Seoane, and R. Solé, Ageing, Computation and the Evolution of Neural Regeneration Processes, J. R. Soc. Interface 17, 0181 (2020).
- M. Chakraborty and E. D. Jarvis, Brain Evolution by Brain Pathway Duplication, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B 370, 0056 (2015).
- O. A. Olulade, A. Seydell-Greenwald, C. E. Chambers, P. E. Turkeltaub, A. W. Dromerick, M. M. Berl, W. D. Gaillard, and E. L. Newport, The Neural Basis of Language Development: Changes in Lateralization over Age, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 117, 23477 (2020).
- L. F. Seoane and R. Solé, Modeling Brain Reorganization after Hemispherectomy, 10.1101/2020.12.25.424412 (2020).
- S. Koelsch, Neural Substrates of Processing Syntax and Semantics in Music, Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 15, 207 (2009).
- D. M. Raup, Geometric Analysis of Shell Coiling: General Problems, J. Paleontol. 40, 1178 (1966).
- J. Tyszka, Morphospace of Foraminiferal Shells: Results from the Moving Reference Model, Lethaia 39, 1 (2006).
- K. J. Niklas, Computer Models of Early Land Plant Evolution, Annu. Rev. Earth Planet Sci. 32, 47 (2004).
- B. Corominas-Murtra, J. Goñi, R. V. Solé, and C. Rodríguez-Caso, On the Origins of Hierarchy in Complex Networks, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 110, 13316 (2013).
- J. Goñi, A. Avena-Koenigsberger, N. Velez de Mendizabal, M. P. van den Heuvel, R. F. Betzel, and O. Sporns, Exploring the Morphospace of Communication Efficiency in Complex Networks, PLoS One 8, e58070 (2013).
- A. Avena-Koenigsberger, J. Goñi, R. Solé, and O. Sporns, Network Morphospace, J. R. Soc. Interface 12, 0881 (2014).
- X. D. Arsiwalla, R. Solé, C. Moulin-Frier, I. Herreros, M. Sanchez-Fibla, and P. Verschure, The Morphospace of Consciousness, arXiv:1705.11190.
- L. F. Seoane and R. Solé, The Morphospace of Language Networks, Sci. Rep. 8, 1 (2018).
- R. Solé and L. F. Seoane, Evolution of Brains and Computers: The Roads Not Taken, Entropy 24, 665 (2022).
- L. F. Seoane, Evolutionary Aspects of Reservoir Computing, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B 374, 0377 (2019).
- D. Duong-Tran, K. Abbas, E. Amico, B. Corominas-Murtra, M. Dzemidzic, D. Kareken, M. Ventresca, and J. Goñi, A Morphospace of Functional Configuration to Assess Configural Breadth Based on Brain Functional Networks, Netw. Neurosci. 5, 666 (2021).
- D. Zhou, C. Lebel, A. Evans, and C. Beaulieu, Cortical Thickness Asymmetry from Childhood to Older Adulthood, NeuroImage 83, 66 (2013).
- K. J. Plessen, K. Hugdahl, R. Bansal, X. Hao, and B. S. Peterson, Sex, Age, and Cognitive Correlates of Asymmetries in Thickness of the Cortical Mantle Across the Life Span, J. Neurosci. 34, 6294 (2014).
- X. Kang, T. J. Herron, M. Ettlinger, and D. L. Woods, Hemispheric Asymmetries in Cortical and Subcortical Anatomy, Laterality 20, 658 (2015).
- S. F. Witelson, The Brain Connection: The Corpus Callosum Is Larger in Left-Handers, Science 229, 665 (1985).
- H. Liepmann, Die linke Hemisphäre und das Handeln. 1, in Drei Aufsätze aus dem Apraxiegebiet (Karger Publishers, Berlin, 1905), pp. 17–50.
- D. Kliemann, R. Adolphs, L. K. Paul, J. M. Tyszka, and D. Tranel, Reorganization of the Social Brain in Individuals with Only One Intact Cerebral Hemisphere, Brain Sci. 11, 965 (2021).
- G. Schlaug, L. Jäncke, Y. Huang, J. F. Staiger, and H. Steinmetz, Increased Corpus Callosum Size in Musicians, Neuropsychologia 33, 1047 (1995).
- H. Steinmetz, Structure, Function and Cerebral Asymmetry: in vivo Morphometry of the Planum Temporale, Neurosci. Biobehav. Rev. 20, 587 (1996).
- J. P. Keenan, V. Thangaraj, A. R. Halpern, and G. Schlaug, Absolute Pitch and Planum Temporale, NeuroImage 14, 1402 (2001).
- H. Markram, The Blue Brain Project, Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 7, 153 (2006).
- I. Hurley, M. E. Hale, and V. E. Prince, Duplication Events and the Evolution of Segmental Identity, Evol. Dev. 7, 556 (2005).
- T. H. Oakley and A. S. Rivera, Genomics and the Evolutionary Origins of Nervous System Complexity, Curr. Opin. Genet. Dev. 18, 479 (2008).
- E. Schneidman, W. Bialek, and M. J. Berry, Synergy, Redundancy, and Independence in Population Codes, J. Neurosci. 23, 11539 (2003).
- X. Pitkow and D. E. Angelaki, Inference in the Brain: Statistics Flowing in Redundant Population Codes, Neuron 94, 943 (2017).
- J. L. Puchalla, E. Schneidman, R. A. Harris, and M. J. Berry, Redundancy in the Population Code of the Retina, Neuron 46, 493 (2005).
- A. Carballo-Castro and L. F. Seoanee, Phase Transitions in a Simple Model of Focal Stroke Imitate Recovery and Suggest Neurorehabilitation Strategies (2022), 10.1101/2022.12.14.520421.
- M. Hiscock and M. Kinsbourne, Phylogeny and Ontogeny of Cerebral Lateralization, in Brain Asymmetry, edited by R. J. Davidson and K. Hugdahl (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1995), pp. 535–578.
- T. Hafting, M. Fyhn, S. Molden, M. B. Moser, and E. I. Moser, Microstructure of a Spatial Map in the Entorhinal Cortex, Nature (London) 436, 801 (2005).
- C. F. Doeller, C. Barry, and N. Burgess, Evidence for Grid Cells in a Human Memory Network, Nature (London) 463, 657 (2010).
- S. S. Kim, H. Rouault, S. Druckmann, and V. Jayaraman, Ring Attractor Dynamics in the Drosophila Central Brain, Science 356, 849 (2017).
