In most cases shell-model calculations are not performed using Hartree-Fock self-consistency conditions. In calculations limited to the valence space, this may not lead to any problems, but when higher shell admixtures are allowed the calculated observables implicitly include Hartree-Fock terms that may be undesirable. In this work, we compare non-self-consistent and nearly self-consistent calculations of the spin-orbit splitting of the and hole states in We find that when higher shell admixtures are included in the model space, and when a “standard” interaction is used, the spin-orbit splitting increases relative to a calculation. However, when the interaction and/or the kinetic energy are modified so as to achieve self-consistency the reverse is true, with the spin-orbit splitting in the space becoming smaller than that in the space. Furthermore, we show that self-consistency cannot be achieved by modifying the two-body spin-orbit or tensor terms, but is possible by adding a monopole-monopole term.