- Open Access
Suppression of sputtering in tungsten fuzz: Interplay of porosity and surface roughness
Phys. Rev. Materials 10, 096001 – Published 2 September, 2026
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/sn2k-xcnw
Abstract
We present a comprehensive study on the sputtering behavior of tungsten fuzz structures under deuterium and argon ion bombardment using three-dimensional simulations. We employed SDTrimSP-3D to investigate porosity as a predictor for the sputtering behavior, complementary to the well-established effects of surface roughness, with simulations conducted across multiple ion energies () and incidence angles (). Fuzz structures were algorithmically generated with varying porosities, and sputter yields were systematically calculated. The findings reveal a universal linear relationship between sputter yield and porosity/volume filling, demonstrating that porosity significantly suppresses sputtering. Importantly, the zero-porosity limit is given by the sputter yield of a rough, but solid surface rather than a flat target. This linear behavior holds consistently across the different ion types and energies for a wide range of incidence angles. When normalized to the rough-surface sputter yield, the slope of the porosity dependence is nearly constant, indicating a common underlying suppression mechanism. The study enhances fundamental understanding of sputtering in porous nanostructures and provides a simple, predictive framework with implications for material design, particularly in nuclear fusion research, where erosion of tungsten fuzz impacts reactor component lifetimes.
Physics Subject Headings (PhySH)
Article Text
References (53)
- R. Garg, S. Gonuguntla, S. Sk, M. S. Iqbal, A. O. Dada, U. Pal, and M. Ahmadipour, Sputtering thin films: Materials, applications, challenges and future directions, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 330, 103203 (2024).
- P. Hajireza, K. Krause, M. Brett, and R. Zemp, Glancing angle deposited nanostructured film Fabry-Perot etalons for optical detection of ultrasound, Opt. Express 21, 6391 (2013).
- C. M. Pieters and S. K. Noble, Space weathering on airless bodies, J. Geophys. Res.: Planets 121, 1865 (2016).
- J. Brötzner, H. Biber, P. S. Szabo, N. Jäggi, L. Fuchs, A. Nenning, M. Fellinger, G. Nagy, E. Pitthan, D. Primetzhofer, A. Mutzke, R. A. Wilhelm, P. Wurz, A. Galli, and F. Aumayr, Solar wind erosion of lunar regolith is suppressed by surface morphology and regolith properties, Commun. Earth Env. 6, 560 (2025).
- H. Biber, J. Brötzner, N. Jäggi, P. S. Szabo, J. Pichler, C. Cupak, C. Voith, B. Cserveny, A. Nenning, A. Mutzke, M. V. Moro, D. Primetzhofer, K. Mezger, A. Galli, P. Wurz, and F. Aumayr, Sputtering behavior of rough, polycrystalline Mercury analogs, Planetary Sci. J. 3, 271 (2022).
- S. Brezinsek, A. Kirschner, M. Mayer, A. Baron-Wiechec, I. Borodkina, D. Borodin, I. Coffey, J. Coenen, N. D. Harder, A. Eksaeva, C. Guillemaut, K. Heinola, A. Huber, V. Huber, M. Imrisek, S. Jachmich, E. Pawelec, M. Rubel, S. Krat, G. Sergienko, et al., Erosion, screening, and migration of tungsten in the JET divertor, Nucl. Fusion 59, 096035 (2019).
- S. Brezinsek, J. Coenen, T. Schwarz-Selinger, K. Schmid, A. Kirschner, A. Hakola, F. Tabares, H. van der Meiden, M.-L. Mayoral, M. Reinhart, et al., Plasma–wall interaction studies within the EUROfusion consortium: progress on plasma-facing components development and qualification, Nucl. Fusion 57, 116041 (2017).
- P. Sigmund, Theory of sputtering. I. Sputtering yield of amorphous and polycrystalline targets, Phys. Rev. 184, 383 (1969).
- W. Eckstein and H. M. Urbassek, Computer simulation ofthe sputtering process, in Sputtering by Particle Bombardment: Experiments and Computer Calculations from Threshold to MeV Energies, Topics in Applied Physics (Springer, Berlin, 2007), pp. 21–31.
- M. Küstner, W. Eckstein, V. Dose, and J. Roth, The influence of surface roughness on the angular dependence of the sputter yield, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. Phys. Res. B 145, 320 (1998).
- C. Cupak, P. S. Szabo, H. Biber, R. Stadlmayr, C. Grave, M. Fellinger, J. Brötzner, R. A. Wilhelm, W. Möller, A. Mutzke, M. V. Moro, and F. Aumayr, Sputter yields of rough surfaces: Importance of the mean surface inclination angle from nano- to microscopic rough regimes, Appl. Surf. Sci. 570, 151204 (2021).
- R. Arredondo, M. Oberkofler, T. Schwarz-Selinger, U. von Toussaint, V. V. Burwitz, A. Mutzke, E. Vassallo, and M. Pedroni, Angle-dependent sputter yield measurements of keV D ions on W and Fe and comparison with SDTrimSP and SDTrimSP-3D, Nucl. Mater. Energy 18, 72 (2019).
- P. S. Szabo, C. Cupak, H. Biber, N. Jäggi, A. Galli, P. Wurz, and F. Aumayr, Analytical model for the sputtering of rough surfaces, Surf. Interfaces 30, 101924 (2022).
- A. Lopez-Cazalilla, C. Cupak, M. Fellinger, F. Granberg, P. S. Szabo, A. Mutzke, K. Nordlund, F. Aumayr, and R. González-Arrabal, Comparative study regarding the sputtering yield of nanocolumnar tungsten surfaces under Ar+ irradiation, Phys. Rev. Mater. 6, 075402 (2022).
- C. Cupak, A. Lopez-Cazalilla, H. Biber, J. Brötzner, M. Fellinger, F. Brandstätter, P. S. Szabo, A. Mutzke, F. Granberg, K. Nordlund, R. González-Arrabal, and F. Aumayr, Sputter yield reduction and fluence stability of numerically optimized nanocolumnar tungsten surfaces, Phys. Rev. Mater. 7, 065406 (2023).
- C. Anders, E. M. Bringa, and H. M. Urbassek, Sputtering of a metal nanofoam by Au ions, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. Phys. Res. B 342, 234 (2015).
- G. Z. Li and R. E. Wirz, Persistent sputtering yield reduction in plasma-infused foams, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 035001 (2021).
- P. S. Szabo, A. R. Poppe, H. Biber, A. Mutzke, J. Pichler, N. Jäggi, A. Galli, P. Wurz, and F. Aumayr, Deducing lunar regolith porosity from energetic neutral atom emission, Geophys. Res. Lett. 49, e2022GL101232 (2022).
- P. S. Szabo, A. R. Poppe, A. Mutzke, S. Fatemi, A. Vorburger, and P. Wurz, Energetic neutral atom (ENA) emission characteristics at the Moon and Mercury from 3D regolith simulations of solar wind reflection, J. Geophys. Res.: Planets 128, e2023JE007911 (2023).
- S. Verkercke, J.-Y. Chaufray, F. Leblanc, E. M. Bringa, D. Tramontina, L. Morrissey, and A. Woodson, Effects of airless bodies' regolith structures and of the solar wind's properties on the backscattered energetic neutral atoms flux, Planetary Sci. J. 4, 197 (2023).
- S. Verkercke, D. Berhanu, C. Bu, B. Clouter-Gergen, F. Leblanc, J. R. Lewis, L. S. Morrissey, and D. W. Savin, Theoretical ion sputtering yields from loose powders using a multiscale Monte Carlo approach, J. Appl. Phys. 139, 145302 (2026).
- M. J. Baldwin and R. P. Doerner, Helium induced nanoscopic morphology on tungsten under fusion relevant plasma conditions, Nucl. Fusion 48, 035001 (2008).
- S. Kajita, W. Sakaguchi, N. Ohno, N. Yoshida, and T. Saeki, Formation process of tungsten nanostructure by the exposure to helium plasma under fusion relevant plasma conditions, Nucl. Fusion 49, 095005 (2009).
- D. Nishijima, M. J. Baldwin, R. P. Doerner, and J. H. Yu, Sputtering properties of tungsten ‘fuzzy’ surfaces, J. Nucl. Mater. 415, S96 (2011).
- K. R. Yang, J. Y. Chen, C. R. Zu, W. Y. Ni, D. P. Liu, S. G. Liu, B. Cui, and S. Y. Dai, Simulations of tungsten fuzz growth and erosion under He/Ar mixed plasma irradiation on LP-MIES, Nucl. Mater. Energy 41, 101797 (2024).
- D. H. Liu, S. Y. Dai, D. Nishijima, K. R. Yang, J. Y. Chen, Y. Xu, and D. Z. Wang, Modelling of tungsten sputtering by argon particle bombardment on a fuzzy surface, Nucl. Mater. Energy 31, 101205 (2022).
- R. Stadlmayr, P. S. Szabo, D. Mayer, C. Cupak, T. Dittmar, L. Bischoff, S. Möller, M. Rasiński, R. A. Wilhelm, W. Möller, and F. Aumayr, Sputtering of nanostructured tungsten and comparison to modelling with TRI3DYN, J. Nucl. Mater. 532, 152019 (2020).
- A. Mutzke, U. v. Toussaint, W. Eckstein, R. Dohmen, and K. Schmid, SDTrimSP version 7.00, IPP Report, 2024, Max-Planck-Institut für Plasmaphysik, doi: 10.17617/2.3577532.
- P. S. Szabo, D. Weichselbaum, H. Biber, C. Cupak, A. Mutzke, R. A. Wilhelm, and F. Aumayr, Graphical user interface for SDTrimSP to simulate sputtering, ion implantation and the dynamic effects of ion irradiation, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. Phys. Res. B 522, 47 (2022).
- U. v. Toussaint, A. Mutzke, and A. Manhard, Sputtering of rough surfaces: A 3D simulation study, Phys. Scr. T170, 014056 (2017).
- A. Mutzke, SDTrimSP-3D: Simulation of particles bombarding on a three dimensional target version 2.5, IPP Report, 2025, Max-Planck-Institut für Plasmaphysik, doi: 10.17617/2.3658013.
- A. Mutzke, R. Schneider, W. Eckstein, R. Dohmen, K. Schmid, U. v. Toussaint, and G. Badelow, SDTrimSP version 6.00, IPP Report, 2019, Max-Planck-Institut für Plasmaphysik, doi: 10.17617/2.3026474.
- W. Eckstein and R. Preuss, New fit formulae for the sputtering yield, J. Nucl. Mater. 320, 209 (2003).
- W. Eckstein, Sputtering yields, in Sputtering by Particle Bombardment: Experiments and Computer Calculations from Threshold to MeV Energies, Topics in Applied Physics (Springer, Berlin, 2007), pp. 33–187.
- E. Pitthan, M. Fellinger, B. B. Domazet, P. M. Wolf, J. Shams-Latifi, F. Aumayr, and D. Primetzhofer, Interaction of light ions with plasma-facing materials: Improved experimental accuracy and its impact on sputter yield simulations, Nucl. Mater. Energy 45, 101996 (2025).
- J. Liang, Y. Li, C.-Y. Zhang, S.-X. Lv, C. Xu, L.-Q. Han, Y.-W. Zhu, Z.-S. Yang, F. Ding, G.-N. Luo, and H.-S. Zhou, Grain orientation and surface nanostructure impact physical sputtering of tungsten by neon plasmas, Nucl. Mater. Energy 46, 102052 (2026).
- A. Golczewski, K. Dobes, G. Wachter, M. Schmid, and F. Aumayr, A quartz-crystal-microbalance technique to investigate ion-induced erosion of fusion relevant surfaces, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. Phys. Res. B 267, 695 (2009).
- W. D. Wilson, L. G. Haggmark, and J. P. Biersack, Calculations of nuclear stopping, ranges, and straggling in the low-energy region, Phys. Rev. B 15, 2458 (1977).
- M. T. Robinson, Tables of classical scattering integrals., Tech. Rep., Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, 1963, https://www.osti.gov/biblio/4646223.
- J. Lindhard and M. Scharff, Energy dissipation by ions in the kev region, Phys. Rev. 124, 128 (1961).
- H. H. Andersen and J. F. Ziegler, Hydrogen. Stopping Powers and Ranges in All Elements (Pergamon Press, New York, 1976).
- J. Brötzner, C. Cupak, M. Fellinger, H. Biber, A. Lopez-Cazalilla, F. Granberg, F. Kporha, A. Mutzke, R. González-Arrabal, and F. Aumayr, Sputtering yield reduction for nano-columnar W surfaces under D ion irradiation, Nucl. Mater. Energy 37, 101507 (2023).
- R. Stadlmayr, P. S. Szabo, D. Mayer, C. Cupak, W. Möller, and F. Aumayr, Erosion of iron-tungsten model films by deuterium ion irradiation: A benchmark for TRI3DYN, Phys. Scr. T171, 014021 (2020).
- M. W. Thompson, II. The energy spectrum of ejected atoms during the high energy sputtering of gold, Philos. Mag. 18, 377 (1968).
- F. Chang, D. Nishijima, M. J. Baldwin, W. Möller, and G. R. Tynan, Hyperspectral imaging and TRI3DYN simulation study of physical sputtering from a fuzzy surface, Nucl. Mater. Energy 38, 101578 (2024).
- L. S. Morrissey, O. J. Tucker, R. M. Killen, S. Nakhla, and D. W. Savin, Sputtering of surfaces by ion irradiation: A comparison of molecular dynamics and binary collision approximation models to laboratory measurements, J. Appl. Phys. 130, 013302 (2021).
- H. Hofsäss and A. Stegmaier, Binary collision approximation simulations of ion solid interaction without the concept of surface binding energies, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. Phys. Res. B 517, 49 (2022).
- N. Jäggi, A. Mutzke, H. Biber, J. Brötzner, P. S. Szabo, F. Aumayr, P. Wurz, and A. Galli, New compound and hybrid binding energy sputter model for modeling purposes in agreement with experimental data, Planetary Sci. J. 4, 86 (2023).
- K. R. Yang, J. Y. Chen, S. Kajita, Q. Shi, C. R. Zu, B. Cui, and S. Y. Dai, Modelling of physical sputtering properties during tungsten fuzz growth under various impact energies on NAGDIS-II, J. Nucl. Mater. 588, 154783 (2024).
- Z. Yang, W. Song, Y. Li, and J. Yang, BCA simulations of ion irradiation of tungsten fuzz, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. Phys. Res. B 455, 118 (2019).
- B. M. Berger, P. S. Szabo, R. Stadlmayr, and F. Aumayr, Sputtering measurements using a quartz crystal microbalance as a catcher, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. Phys. Res. B 406, 533 (2017), The 27th International Conference on Atomic Collisions in Solids.
- M. Li, N. Ulrich, I. Schubert, W. Sigle, M. F. P. Wagner, C. Trautmann, and M. E. Toimil-Molares, Three-dimensional free-standing gold nanowire networks as a platform for catalytic applications, RSC Adv. 13, 4721 (2023).
- J. Brötzner, Data for: “Suppression of sputtering in tungsten fuzz: Interplay of porosity and surface roughness” [Dataset], TU Wien, 2026, https://doi.org/10.48436/k3gc1-gq315