• Accepted Paper

Benchmark for self-organized criticality

Alexander Shapoval, Boris Shapoval, and Mikhail Shnirman

Phys. Rev. E - Accepted 17 November, 2026

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/rt9t-l9df

Abstract

Revisiting the Bak–Tang–Wiesenfeld (BTW) sandpile model, we examine the structure of the avalanche size-frequency relationship traditionally interpreted as scale free. Using large-scale simulations on lattices up to L=16384, we show that the apparent power-law range preceding the finite-size cutoff is not homogeneous but instead consists of two distinct regimes that both expand with system size. The intermediate-size regime exhibits behavior consistent with a robust power law. In contrast, the large-size regime displays systematic deviations from this power law. While its functional form cannot be determined conclusively, a local power-law approximation suggests an exponent that is close to, but distinct from, that of the intermediate regime. Motivated by this structure, we introduce a modified sandpile model that mixes slow driving and fast relaxation processes, allowing for the spatial and temporal combination of avalanches. For a specific scaling of the model parameters with system size, the resulting dynamics produce a size–frequency relationship consistent with a single power law across the full scaling range, followed by a finite-size cutoff. The corresponding exponent is estimated to be 1.217. These findings suggest that the classical BTW model approximates, but does not fully realize, scale invariance, and that small modifications of the driving mechanism can restore a unified critical behavior.

Export citation

Export citation

Choose format for download:

Download Citation

If the author has provided any supplemental materials with this article they will be available upon publication of the version of record.

Sign In to Your Journals Account

Filter

Filter

Article Lookup

Enter a citation