- Open Access
First full physics benchmark for highly granular calorimeter surrogates
Phys. Rev. D 114, 092009 – Published 13 November, 2026
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/fn99-hq7q
Abstract
The physics programs of current and future collider experiments necessitate the development of surrogate simulators for calorimeter showers. While much progress has been made in the development of generative models for this task, they have typically been evaluated in simplified scenarios and for single particles. This is particularly true for the challenging task of highly granular calorimeter simulation. For the first time, this work studies the use of highly granular generative calorimeter surrogates in a realistic simulation application. We introduce DDML (dd4hep with machine learning), a generic library which enables the combination of generative calorimeter surrogates with realistic detectors implemented using the dd4hep toolkit. We compare two different generative models—one operating on a regular grid representation and the other using a less common point cloud approach. In order to disentangle methodological details from model performance, we provide comparisons to idealized simulators which directly sample representations of different resolutions from the full simulation ground truth. We then systematically evaluate model performance on post-reconstruction benchmarks for electromagnetic shower simulation. Beginning with a typical single-particle study, we introduce a first multiparticle benchmark based on diphoton separations, before studying a first full physics benchmark based on hadronic decays of the tau lepton. Our results indicate that models operating on a point cloud can achieve a favorable balance between speed and accuracy for highly granular calorimeter simulation compared to those which operate on a regular grid representation.
Physics Subject Headings (PhySH)
Article Text
References (99)
- J. Albrecht et al. (HEP Software Foundation Collaboration), A roadmap for HEP software and computing R&D for the 2020s, Comput. Softw. Big Sci. 3, 7 (2019).
- A. Boehnlein, C. Biscarat, A. Bressan, D. Britton, R. Bolton, F. Gaede, C. Grandi, F. Hernandez, T. Kuhr, G. Merino, F. Simon, and G. Watts, HL-LHC software and computing review panel, 2nd Report, Technical Report No. CERN-LHCC-2022-007, LHCC-G-183, CERN, Geneva, 2022.
- M. Paganini, L. de Oliveira, and B. Nachman, Accelerating science with generative adversarial networks: An application to 3D particle showers in multilayer calorimeters, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 042003 (2018).
- M. Paganini, L. de Oliveira, and B. Nachman, CaloGAN: Simulating 3D high energy particle showers in multilayer electromagnetic calorimeters with generative adversarial networks, Phys. Rev. D 97, 014021 (2018).
- L. de Oliveira, M. Paganini, and B. Nachman, Controlling physical attributes in GAN-accelerated simulation of electromagnetic calorimeters, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 1085, 042017 (2018).
- M. Erdmann, L. Geiger, J. Glombitza, and D. Schmidt, Generating and refining particle detector simulations using the Wasserstein distance in adversarial networks, Comput. Softw. Big Sci. 2, 4 (2018).
- M. Erdmann, J. Glombitza, and T. Quast, Precise simulation of electromagnetic calorimeter showers using a Wasserstein generative adversarial network, Comput. Softw. Big Sci. 3, 4 (2019).
- F. Carminati, A. Gheata, G. Khattak, P. Mendez Lorenzo, S. Sharan, and S. Vallecorsa, Three dimensional generative adversarial networks for fast simulation, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 1085, 032016 (2018).
- P. Musella and F. Pandolfi, Fast and accurate simulation of particle detectors using generative adversarial networks, Comput. Softw. Big Sci. 2, 8 (2018).
- D. Belayneh et al., Calorimetry with deep learning: Particle simulation and reconstruction for collider physics, Eur. Phys. J. C 80, 688 (2020).
- A. Butter, S. Diefenbacher, G. Kasieczka, B. Nachman, and T. Plehn, GANplifying event samples, SciPost Phys. 10, 139 (2021).
- ATLAS Collaboration, Fast simulation of the ATLAS calorimeter system with Generative Adversarial Networks, Technical Report No. ATL-SOFT-PUB-2020-006, CERN, Geneva, 2020.
- A. Ghosh (ATLAS Collaboration), Deep generative models for fast shower simulation in ATLAS, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 1525, 012077 (2020).
- G. Aad et al. (ATLAS Collaboration), AtlFast3: The next generation of fast simulation in ATLAS, Comput. Softw. Big Sci. 6, 7 (2022).
- G. Aad et al. (ATLAS Collaboration), Deep generative models for fast photon shower simulation in ATLAS, Comput. Softw. Big Sci. 8, 7 (2024).
- B. Hashemi, N. Hartmann, S. Sharifzadeh, J. Kahn, and T. Kuhr, Ultra-high-granularity detector simulation with intra-event aware generative adversarial network and self-supervised relational reasoning, Nat. Commun. 15, 4916 (2024); 15, 5825(E) (2024).
- M. Faucci Giannelli and R. Zhang, CaloShowerGAN, a generative adversarial network model for fast calorimeter shower simulation, Eur. Phys. J. Plus 139, 597 (2024).
- E. Simsek, B. Isildak, A. Dogru, R. Aydogan, A. B. Bayrak, and S. Ertekin, CALPAGAN: Calorimetry for particles using generative adversarial networks, Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2024, 083C01 (2024).
- E. Buhmann, S. Diefenbacher, E. Eren, F. Gaede, G. Kasieczka, A. Korol, and K. Krüger, Getting high: High fidelity simulation of high granularity calorimeters with high speed, Comput. Softw. Big Sci. 5, 13 (2021).
- E. Buhmann, S. Diefenbacher, E. Eren, F. Gaede, G. Kasieczka, A. Korol, and K. Krüger, Decoding photons: Physics in the latent space of a BIB-AE generative network, EPJ Web Conf. 251, 03003 (2021).
- E. Buhmann, S. Diefenbacher, D. Hundhausen, G. Kasieczka, W. Korcari, E. Eren, F. Gaede, K. Krüger, P. McKeown, and L. Rustige, Hadrons, better, faster, stronger, Mach. Learn. Sci. Tech. 3, 025014 (2022).
- J. C. Cresswell, B. L. Ross, G. Loaiza-Ganem, H. Reyes-Gonzalez, M. Letizia, and A. L. Caterini, CaloMan: Fast generation of calorimeter showers with density estimation on learned manifolds, in 36th Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems: Workshop on Machine Learning and the Physical Sciences (2022), arXiv:2211.15380.
- S. Bieringer, A. Butter, S. Diefenbacher, E. Eren, F. Gaede, D. Hundhausen, G. Kasieczka, B. Nachman, T. Plehn, and M. Trabs, Calomplification—the power of generative calorimeter models, J. Instrum. 17, P09028 (2022).
- S. Diefenbacher, E. Eren, F. Gaede, G. Kasieczka, A. Korol, K. Krüger, P. McKeown, and L. Rustige, New angles on fast calorimeter shower simulation, Mach. Learn. Sci. Tech. 4, 035044 (2023).
- S. Hoque, H. Jia, A. Abhishek, M. Fadaie, J. Q. Toledo-Marín, T. Vale, R. G. Melko, M. Swiatlowski, and W. T. Fedorko, CaloQVAE: Simulating high-energy particle-calorimeter interactions using hybrid quantum-classical generative models, Eur. Phys. J. C 84, 1244 (2024).
- Q. Liu, C. Shimmin, X. Liu, E. Shlizerman, S. Li, and S.-C. Hsu, Calo-VQ: Vector-quantized two-stage generative model in calorimeter simulation, arXiv:2405.06605.
- C. Krause and D. Shih, Fast and accurate simulations of calorimeter showers with normalizing flows, Phys. Rev. D 107, 113003 (2023).
- C. Krause and D. Shih, Accelerating accurate simulations of calorimeter showers with normalizing flows and probability density distillation, Phys. Rev. D 107, 113004 (2023).
- S. Schnake, B. Kach, M. Scham, D. Krücker, K. Borras, and S. Vallecorsa, CaloPointFlow–generating calorimeter showers as point clouds, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 3206, 012108 (2026).
- C. Krause, I. Pang, and D. Shih, CaloFlow for CaloChallenge dataset 1, SciPost Phys. 16, 126 (2024).
- S. Diefenbacher, E. Eren, F. Gaede, G. Kasieczka, C. Krause, I. Shekhzadeh, and D. Shih, L2LFlows: Generating high-fidelity 3D calorimeter images, J. Instrum. 18, P10017 (2023).
- A. Xu, S. Han, X. Ju, and H. Wang, Generative machine learning for detector response modeling with a conditional normalizing flow, J. Instrum. 19, P02003 (2024).
- M. R. Buckley, C. Krause, I. Pang, and D. Shih, Inductive simulation of calorimeter showers with normalizing flows, Phys. Rev. D 109, 033006 (2024).
- I. Pang, D. Shih, and J. A. Raine, Calorimeter shower superresolution, Phys. Rev. D 109, 092009 (2024).
- F. Ernst, L. Favaro, C. Krause, T. Plehn, and D. Shih, Normalizing flows for high-dimensional detector simulations, SciPost Phys. 18, 081 (2025).
- S. Schnake, D. Krücker, and K. Borras, CaloPointFlow II Generating calorimeter showers as point clouds, arXiv:2403.15782.
- H. Du, C. Krause, V. Mikuni, B. Nachman, I. Pang, and D. Shih, Unifying simulation and inference with normalizing flows, Phys. Rev. D 111, 076004 (2025).
- T. Buss, F. Gaede, G. Kasieczka, C. Krause, and D. Shih, Convolutional L2LFlows: Generating accurate showers in highly granular calorimeters using convolutional normalizing flows, J. Instrum. 19, P09003 (2024).
- J. Birk, F. Gaede, A. Hallin, G. Kasieczka, M. Mozzanica, and H. Rose, OmniJet-_C: Learning point cloud calorimeter simulations using generative transformers, J. Instrum. 20, P07007 (2025).
- V. Mikuni and B. Nachman, Score-based generative models for calorimeter shower simulation, Phys. Rev. D 106, 092009 (2022).
- E. Buhmann, S. Diefenbacher, E. Eren, F. Gaede, G. Kasieczka, A. Korol, W. Korcari, K. Krüger, and P. McKeown, CaloClouds: Fast geometry-independent highly-granular calorimeter simulation, J. Instrum. 18, P11025 (2023).
- F. T. Acosta, V. Mikuni, B. Nachman, M. Arratia, B. Karki, R. Milton, P. Karande, and A. Angerami, Comparison of point cloud and image-based models for calorimeter fast simulation, J. Instrum. 19, P05003 (2024).
- V. Mikuni and B. Nachman, CaloScore v2: Single-shot calorimeter shower simulation with diffusion models, J. Instrum. 19, P02001 (2024).
- O. Amram and K. Pedro, Denoising diffusion models with geometry adaptation for high fidelity calorimeter simulation, Phys. Rev. D 108, 072014 (2023).
- E. Buhmann, F. Gaede, G. Kasieczka, A. Korol, W. Korcari, K. Krüger, and P. McKeown, CaloClouds II: Ultra-fast geometry-independent highly-granular calorimeter simulation, J. Instrum. 19, P04020 (2024).
- C. Jiang, S. Qian, and H. Qu, Choose your diffusion: Efficient and flexible ways to accelerate the diffusion model in fast high energy physics simulation, SciPost Phys. 18, 195 (2025).
- D. Kobylianskii, N. Soybelman, E. Dreyer, and E. Gross, Graph-based diffusion model for fast shower generation in calorimeters with irregular geometry, Phys. Rev. D 110, 072003 (2024).
- C. Jiang, S. Qian, and H. Qu, BUFF: Boosted decision tree based ultra-fast flow matching, arXiv:2404.18219.
- L. Favaro, A. Ore, S. P. Schweitzer, and T. Plehn, CaloDREAM—detector response emulation via attentive flow matching, SciPost Phys. 18, 088 (2025).
- J. Brehmer, V. Bresó, P. de Haan, T. Plehn, H. Qu, J. Spinner, and J. Thaler, A Lorentz-equivariant transformer for all of the LHC, SciPost Phys. 19, 108 (2025).
- T. Buss, F. Gaede, G. Kasieczka, A. Korol, K. Krüger, P. McKeown, and M. Mozzanica, CaloHadronic: A diffusion model for the generation of hadronic showers, J. Instrum. 21, P01042 (2026).
- P. Raikwar, A. Zaborowska, P. McKeown, R. Cardoso, M. Piorczynski, and K. Yeo, A generalisable generative model for multi-detector calorimeter simulation, arXiv:2509.07700.
- B. Hashemi and C. Krause, Deep generative models for detector signature simulation: A taxonomic review, Rev. Phys. 12, 100092 (2024).
- O. Amram et al., CaloChallenge 2022: A community challenge for fast calorimeter simulation, Rep. Prog. Phys. 88, 116201 (2025).
- Photon showers in the ATLAS fast calorimeter simulation: A voxelized dataset with minimized information loss and improved ML models, CERN Technical Report No. ATL-SOFT-PUB-2025-003, 2025, https://cds.cern.ch/record/2942061.
- CMS Collaboration, The phase-2 upgrade of the CMS endcap calorimeter, CERN Technical Report Nos. CERN-LHCC-2017-023 and CMS-TDR-019, 2017, https://cds.cern.ch/record/2293646.
- H. Abramowicz et al. (ILD Concept Group Collaboration), International Large Detector: Interim Design Report, arXiv:2003.01116.
- N. Bacchetta et al., CLD—a detector concept for the FCC-ee, Technical Report No. LCD-Note-2019-001, 2019, https://cds.cern.ch/record/2697140.
- F. Gaede, T. Madlener, P. McKeown, T. Buss, A. Zaborowska, and A. Korol, key4hep/ddml: v0.2.0, Zenodo, 10.5281/zenodo.17475367(2025).
- M. Frank, F. Gaede, C. Grefe, and P. Mato, dd4hep: A detector description toolkit for high energy physics experiments, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 513, 022010 (2014).
- T. Buss, H. Day-Hall, F. Gaede, G. Kasieczka, K. Krüger, A. Korol, T. Madlener, P. McKeown, M. Mozzanica, and L. Valente, Caloclouds3: Ultra-fast geometry-independent highly-granular calorimeter simulation, J. Instrum. 21, P03018 (2026).
- J. Repond et al. (CALICE Collaboration), Design and electronics commissioning of the physics prototype of a Si-W electromagnetic calorimeter for the international linear collider, J. Instrum. 3, P08001 (2008).
- C. Adloff et al. (CALICE Collaboration), Construction and commissioning of the CALICE analog hadron calorimeter prototype, J. Instrum. 5, P05004 (2010).
- V. Völkl et al., The key4hep turnkey software stack, Proc. Sci. ICHEP2022 (2022) 234.
- S. Agostinelli et al. (GEANT4 Collaboration), geant4—A simulation toolkit, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. A 506, 250 (2003).
- P. McKeown, Development and performance of a fast simulation tool for showers in high granularity calorimeters based on deep generative models, Ph.D. thesis, Hamburg U., Hamburg, 2024.
- A. Korol, H. Day-Hall, and F. Gaede, Caloclouds3 training data, Zenodo, 10.5281/zenodo.18662706(2026).
- J. S. Marshall and M. A. Thomson, The Pandora software development kit for pattern recognition, Eur. Phys. J. C 75, 439 (2015).
- B. Xu, Improvement of photon reconstruction in pandorapfa, in International Workshop on Future Linear Colliders (2016), arXiv:1603.00013.
- M. Dam, The challenges at FCC-ee, Eur. Phys. J. Plus 136, 963 (2021).
- L. Calibbi, X. Marcano, and J. Roy, Z lepton flavour violation as a probe for new physics at future colliders, Eur. Phys. J. C 81, 1054 (2021).
- S. Jahedi and A. Sarkar, Exploring optimal sensitivity of lepton flavor violating effective couplings at the colliders, Phys. Rev. D 110, 095021 (2024).
- A. Gutiérrez-Rodríguez, C. Pérez-Mayorga, and A. González-Sánchez, Sensitivity estimates on the electromagnetic dipole moments of the -lepton at future linear colliders, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 61, 132 (2022).
- J. de Blas, M. Cepeda, J. D’Hondt, R. K. Ellis, C. Grojean, B. Heinemann, F. Maltoni, A. Nisati, E. Petit, R. Rattazzi, and W. Verkerke, Higgs boson studies at future particle colliders, J. High Energy Phys. 01 (2020) 139.
- T. H. Tran, V. Balagura, V. Boudry, J.-C. Brient, and H. Videau, Reconstruction and classification of tau lepton decays with ILD, Eur. Phys. J. C 76, 468 (2016).
- D. Jeans, Tau lepton reconstruction at collider experiments using impact parameters, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. A 810, 51 (2016).
- S. Berge, W. Bernreuther, and H. Spiesberger, Higgs properties using the decay modes at the ILC, Phys. Lett. B 727, 488 (2013).
- D. Jeans and G. W. Wilson, Measuring the state of tau lepton pairs from Higgs decay at the ILC, Phys. Rev. D 98, 013007 (2018).
- S. Navas et al. (Particle Data Group), Review of particle physics, Phys. Rev. D 110, 030001 (2024).
- H. Ono and A. Miyamoto, Status of ILD new 250 GeV common MC sample production, in International Workshop on Future Linear Colliders (2021), arXiv:2105.06040.
- W. Kilian, T. Ohl, and J. Reuter, whizard: Simulating multi-particle processes at LHC and ILC, Eur. Phys. J. C 71, 1742 (2011).
- S. Jadach, J. H. Kuhn, and Z. Was, TAUOLA: A Library of Monte Carlo programs to simulate decays of polarized tau leptons, Comput. Phys. Commun. 64, 275 (1990).
- L. Dinh, D. Krueger, and Y. Bengio, NICE: Non-linear independent components estimation, arXiv:1410.8516.
- C. Durkan, A. Bekasov, I. Murray, and G. Papamakarios, Neural spline flows, arXiv:1906.04032.
- O. Ronneberger, P. Fischer, and T. Brox, U-net: Convolutional networks for biomedical image segmentation, in Medical Image Computing and Computer-Assisted Intervention (MICCAI), LNCS, Vol. 9351 (Springer, New York, 2015), pp. 234–241.
- T. Buss, H. Day-Hall, F. Gaede, G. Kasieczka, and K. Krüger, AllShowers: One model for all calorimeter showers, arXiv:2601.11716.
- S. Campana, WLCG Strategy 2024-2027, Zenodo, 10.5281/zenodo.12623280 (2024).
- B. Xu, Detectors and physics at a future linear collider, Ph.D. thesis, Cambridge U., 2017, 10.17863/CAM.16867.
- B. List and J. List (DESY Collaboration), MarlinKinfit: An object-oriented kinematic fitting package, LC Notes 10.3204/PHPPUBDB-10294 (2009).
- M. Mlynarikova, Design and performance of the calorimeter system for allegro Fcc-ee detector concept, EPJ Web Conf. 320, 00022 (2025).
- L. Lee, C. Ohm, A. Soffer, and T.-T. Yu, Collider Searches for long-lived particles beyond the standard model, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 106, 210 (2019); 122, 103912(E) (2022).
- It’s about time: A point cloud generative model for the CMS high granularity calorimeter, Technical Report, CERN, Geneva, 2025.
- C. Joram et al., Extension of the R&D programme on technologies for future experiments, CERN Technical Report No. CERN-EP-RDET-2023-001, https://cds.cern.ch/record/2850809.
- https://github.com/key4hep/DDML.
- J. Allison et al. (GEANT4 Collaboration), Par04 example, https://github.com/Geant4/geant4/tree/master/examples/extended/parameterisations/Par04 (2025) (accessed: 06.08.2025).
- A. Paszke et al., pytorch: An Imperative Style, High-Performance Deep Learning Library, in Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems (Curran Associates, Inc., 2019), Vol. 32, pp. 8024–8035.
- O. R. developers, ONNX Runtime, https://onnxruntime.ai/ (2021) (accessed: 30.12.2023).
- A. Boehnlein, C. Biscarat, A. Bressan, D. Britton, R. Bolton, F. Gaede, C. Grandi, F. Hernandez, T. Kuhr, G. Merino, F. Simon, and G. Watts, HL-LHC software and computing review panel, 2nd Report, CERN Technical Report Nos. CERN-LHCC-2022-007 and LHCC-G-183, 2022, https://cds.cern.ch/record/2803119.
- E. Bingham, J. P. Chen, M. Jankowiak, F. Obermeyer, N. Pradhan, T. Karaletsos, R. Singh, P. A. Szerlip, P. Horsfall, and N. D. Goodman, pyro: Deep universal probabilistic programming, J. Mach. Learn. Res. 20, 1 (2019).