We present a comparison of various approximations to the self-consistent methods, including the one-shot method, different quasiparticle self-consistent schemes, and the fully self-consistent approach. To ensure an unbiased and equitable comparison, we have implemented all the schemes with the same underlying Matsubara formalism, while employing Gaussian orbitals to describe the system. Aiming to assess and compare different schemes, we analyze band gaps in semiconductors and insulators, as well as ionization potentials in molecules. Our findings reveal that for solids, the different self-consistent schemes perform very similarly. However, for molecules, full self-consistency outperforms all other approximations, i.e., the one-shot and quasiparticle self-consistent methods. Our work highlights the importance of implementation details when comparing different methods. By employing state-of-the-art fully self-consistent, finite temperature calculations, we have successfully addressed discrepancies in the existing literature regarding its performance. Our results also indicate that when stringent thresholds are imposed, the method consistently yields accurate results.