Contrasting magnetism in and monolayers with the common honeycomb spin lattice
Ke Yang, Yueyue Ning, Yaozhenghang Ma, Yuxuan Zhou, and Hua Wu
Phys. Rev. B 111, 134421 (2025) - Published 15 April, 2025
Two-dimensional (2D) magnetic materials are promising candidates for spintronics and quantum technologies. One extensively studied example is the ferromagnetic (FM) monolayer with the honeycomb ( = 3/2) spin lattice, while has the same honeycomb = 3/2 spin lattice () but displays Néel antiferromagnetism. In this paper, we study the electronic structure and particularly the contrasting magnetism of and monolayers, using density functional calculations, magnetic exchange pictures, maximally localized Wannier function (MLWF) analysis, and parallel tempering Monte Carlo simulations. We find that is a Mott-Hubbard insulator but is a charge-transfer insulator, and therefore their magnetic exchange mechanisms are essentially different. The first-nearest-neighbor (1NN) direct exchange dominates in , thus leading to a strong antiferromagnetic (AF) coupling. However, the formation of vanadium vacancies, associated with instability of the low-valence ions, suppresses the AF coupling and thus strongly reduces the Néel temperature () in line with experimental observation. In contrast, our results reveal that the major 1NN superexchanges in via different channels give rise to competing FM and AF couplings, ultimately resulting in a weak FM coupling as observed experimentally. After revisiting several important superexchange channels reported in the literature, based on our MLWF and tight-binding analyses, we note that some antiphase contributions must be subtly and simultaneously considered, and thus we provide a deeper insight into the FM coupling of . Moreover, we identify and compare the major contributions to the magnetic anisotropy, i.e., a weak shape anisotropy in and a relatively strong exchange anisotropy in . Our paper offers a comprehensive understanding of 2D magnetism using spin-orbital states and distinct exchange channels.

