Hydrogen in its metallic form is the most common material in our solar system, found under the extreme pressure and temperature conditions found in giant planets. Such conditions are inaccessible to experiments and, consequently, theoretical work has typically led experiments. Metallic hydrogen is also expected to exist in solid form at low temperatures and to have remarkable properties. It has been the subject of several controversial claims of synthesis. A curious feature is that solid metallic hydrogen is not expected to have a close-packed structure, even at extreme pressures. The predicted crystal structure has a packing fraction of only 0.44 compared with 0.74 for fcc. Alloying with other metallic elements can form compounds with atomic hydrogen and much reduced metallization pressure. Here we investigate the possible solid solubility of a representative range of elements (Be, B, Mg, S, Fe, La) in metallic atomic hydrogen near 500 GPa. We find that zero point energy is a highly significant feature in all cases. The metallic elements Be, Mg, Fe, and La have a well-defined clathrate-style first-neighbor shell at 300 K, while the nonmetallic B and S have more open arrangements. All the elements considered are soluble, in sites substituting for more than one hydrogen atom. The solid solubility of such a wide range of ambient bonding types—simple metals, covalent materials, transition metals, lanthanides—gives a strong indication that most elements will dissolve in solid metallic hydrogen. Atomic metallic hydrogen is far more aggressively corrosive than its molecular counterpart, which adds to the practical challenge for synthesis. Such doping raises the possibility of synthesizing /amd hydrogen at somewhat lower pressure.