- Open Access
Membrane bending energy selects for symmetric growth of protein assemblies
Phys. Rev. Research 8, 043025 – Published 8 October, 2026
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/tnv7-fjh5
Abstract
Membrane remodeling into vesicles is essential for processes such as receptor transport and viral budding. In many cases, this remodeling is driven by the assembly of multivalent protein lattices that stochastically grow while coupled to bending the membrane. Here, we ask how membrane mechanics can bias the structural pathways sampled during lattice growth. Using a continuum membrane model coupled to growing human immunodeficiency virus Gag lattice intermediates, we show that radially symmetric lattice growth is energetically favored over eccentric growth because it induces membrane bending at lower cost per protein. For rigid lattices, the penalty for asymmetric growth is controlled primarily by the shape of the lattice perimeter rather than by the density of protein-membrane links, with all membrane deformations retaining strong radial symmetry. Reevaluating the energy relative to the circumscribing radius of the lattice thus collapses all growth pathways to a similar curve. When the lattice is flexible, asymmetric growth introduces another cost, as these intermediates also generate weaker curvature. Analytical spherical-cap estimates support the trends in our numerical energy minimization calculations, and our results remain robust across a range of tested modeling assumptions including membrane spontaneous curvature. Although kinetic barriers along growth pathways are not assessed, our results show that membrane bending can strongly select for symmetric assembly pathways, providing a mechanical bias against irregular lattice growth during membrane remodeling.
Physics Subject Headings (PhySH)
Article Text
Supplemental Material
References (107)
- F. A. Barr and U. Gruneberg, Cytokinesis: Placing and making the final cut, Cell 131, 847 (2007).
- M. Kaksonen and A. Roux, Mechanisms of clathrin-mediated endocytosis, Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 19, 313 (2018).
- E. O. Freed and A. J. Mouland, The cell biology of HIV-1 and other retroviruses, Retrovirology 3, 77 (2006).
- T. Baumgart, B. R. Capraro, C. Zhu, and S. L. Das, Thermodynamics and mechanics of membrane curvature generation and sensing by proteins and lipids, Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 62, 483 (2011).
- F. Campelo, H. T. McMahon, and M. M. Kozlov, The hydrophobic insertion mechanism of membrane curvature generation by proteins, Biophys. J. 95, 2325 (2008).
- N. Yandrapalli, Q. Lubart, H. S. Tanwar, C. Picart, J. Mak, D. Muriaux, and C. Favard, Self assembly of HIV-1 Gag protein on lipid membranes generates PI(4,5)P2/Cholesterol nanoclusters, Sci. Rep. 6, 39332 (2016).
- A. J. Bryer, T. Reddy, E. Lyman, and J. R. Perilla, Full scale structural, mechanical and dynamical properties of HIV-1 liposomes, PLoS Comput. Biol. 18, e1009781 (2022).
- Z. G. Denieva, P. I. Kuzmin, T. R. Galimzyanov, S. A. K. Datta, A. Rein, and O. V. Batishchev, Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Gag polyprotein modulates membrane physical properties like a surfactant: Potential implications for virus assembly, ACS Infect. Dis. 10, 2870 (2024).
- E. R. May and C. L. Brooks, Determination of viral capsid elastic properties from equilibrium thermal fluctuations, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 188101 (2011).
- I. L. Ivanovska, P. J. de Pablo, B. Ibarra, G. Sgalari, F. C. MacKintosh, J. L. Carrascosa, C. F. Schmidt, and G. J. Wuite, Bacteriophage capsids: Tough nanoshells with complex elastic properties, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 101, 7600 (2004).
- J. Harrison, D. O. Passos, J. F. Bruhn, J. D. Bauman, L. Tuberty, J. J. DeStefano, F. X. Ruiz, D. Lyumkis, and E. Arnold, Cryo-EM structure of the HIV-1 Pol polyprotein provides insights into virion maturation, Sci. Adv. 8, eabn9874 (2022).
- F. K. M. Schur, M. Obr, W. J. H. Hagen, W. Wan, A. J. Jakobi, J. M. Kirkpatrick, C. Sachse, H.-G. Kräusslich, and J. A. G. Briggs, An atomic model of HIV-1 capsid-SP1 reveals structures regulating assembly and maturation, Science 353, 506 (2016).
- S. Mattei, A. Tan, B. Glass, B. Müller, H.-G. Kräusslich, and J. A. G. Briggs, High-resolution structures of HIV-1 Gag cleavage mutants determine structural switch for virus maturation, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 115, E9401 (2018).
- A. Tan, A. J. Pak, D. R. Morado, G. A. Voth, and J. A. G. Briggs, Immature HIV-1 assembles from Gag dimers leaving partial hexamers at lattice edges as potential substrates for proteolytic maturation, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 118, e2020054118 (2021).
- L. Mendonça, D. Sun, J. Ning, J. Liu, A. Kotecha, M. Olek, T. Frosio, X. Fu, B. A. Himes, A. B. Kleinpeter, E. O. Freed, J. Zhou, C. Aiken, and P. Zhang, CryoET structures of immature HIV Gag reveal six-helix bundle, Commun. Biol. 4, 481 (2021).
- J. A. G. Briggs, M. N. Simon, I. Gross, H.-G. Kräusslich, S. D. Fuller, V. M. Vogt, and M. C. Johnson, The stoichiometry of Gag protein in HIV-1, Nat. Struct. Mol. Biol. 11, 672 (2004).
- J. Hendrix, V. Baumgärtel, W. Schrimpf, S. Ivanchenko, M. A. Digman, E. Gratton, H.-G. Kräusslich, B. Müller, and D. C. Lamb, Live-cell observation of cytosolic HIV-1 assembly onset reveals RNA-interacting Gag oligomers, J. Cell Biol. 210, 629 (2015).
- M. Tritel and M. D. Resh, Kinetic analysis of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 assembly reveals the presence of sequential intermediates, J. Virol. 74, 5845 (2000).
- S.-K. Guo, A. J. Sodt, and M. E. Johnson, Large self-assembled clathrin lattices spontaneously disassemble without sufficient adaptor proteins, PLoS Comput. Biol. 18, e1009969 (2022).
- M. Deserno, Elastic deformation of a fluid membrane upon colloid binding, Phys. Rev. E 69, 031903 (2004).
- C. Vanhille-Campos, K. D. Whitley, P. Radler, M. Loose, S. Holden, and A. Šarić, Self-organization of mortal filaments and its role in bacterial division ring formation, Nat. Phys. 20, 1670 (2024).
- I. Kucharska, P. Ding, K. K. Zadrozny, R. A. Dick, M. F. Summers, B. K. Ganser-Pornillos, and O. Pornillos, Biochemical reconstitution of HIV-1 assembly and maturation, J. Virol. 94, e01844 (2020).
- D. L. Bush and V. M. Vogt, In vitro assembly of retroviruses, Annu. Rev. Virol. 1, 561 (2014).
- M. J. Varga, Y. Fu, S. Loggia, O. N. Yogurtcu, and M. E. Johnson, NERDSS: A nonequilibrium simulator for multibody self-assembly at the cellular scale, Biophys. J. 118, 3026 (2020).
- Y. Qian, D. Evans, B. Mishra, Y. Fu, Z. H. Liu, S. Guo, and M. E. Johnson, Temporal control by cofactors prevents kinetic trapping in retroviral Gag lattice assembly, Biophys. J. 122, 3173 (2023).
- S. Guo, I. Saha, S. Saffarian, and M. E. Johnson, Structure of the HIV immature lattice allows for essential lattice remodeling within budded virions, eLife 12, e84881 (2023).
- F. K. M. Schur, W. J. H. Hagen, M. Rumlová, T. š Ruml, B. Müller, H.-G. Kräusslich, and J. A. G. Briggs, Structure of the immature HIV-1 capsid in intact virus particles at 8.8 Å resolution, Nature (London) 517, 505 (2015).
- A. J. Pak, M. Gupta, M. Yeager, and G. A. Voth, Inositol hexakisphosphate (IP6) accelerates immature HIV-1 Gag protein assembly toward kinetically trapped morphologies, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 144, 10417 (2022).
- A. Jhaveri, S. Loggia, Y. Qian, and M. E. Johnson, Discovering optimal kinetic pathways for self-assembly using automatic differentiation, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 121, e2403384121 (2024).
- F. Feng and W. S. Klug, Finite element modeling of lipid bilayer membranes, J. Comput. Phys. 220, 394 (2006).
- Y. Fu, W. F. Zeno, J. C. Stachowiak, and M. E. Johnson, A continuum membrane model can predict curvature sensing by helix insertion, Soft Matter 17, 10649 (2021).
- F. Mohajerani, B. Tyukodi, C. J. Schlicksup, J. A. Hadden-Perilla, A. Zlotnick, and M. F. Hagan, Multiscale modeling of hepatitis B virus capsid assembly and its dimorphism, ACS Nano 16, 13845 (2022).
- M. F. Hagan and R. Zandi, Recent advances in coarse-grained modeling of virus assembly, Curr. Opin. Virol. 18, 36 (2016).
- A. J. Pak, J. M. A. Grime, P. Sengupta, A. K. Chen, A. E. P. Durumeric, A. Srivastava, M. Yeager, J. A. G. Briggs, J. Lippincott-Schwartz, and G. A. Voth, Immature HIV-1 lattice assembly dynamics are regulated by scaffolding from nucleic acid and the plasma membrane, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 114, E10056 (2017).
- M. Gupta, A. J. Pak, and G. A. Voth, Critical mechanistic features of HIV-1 viral capsid assembly, Sci. Adv. 9, eadd7434 (2023).
- S. Timmermans, A. Ramezani, T. Montalvo, M. Nguyen, P. van der Schoot, J. C. M. van Hest, and R. Zandi, The dynamics of viruslike capsid assembly and disassembly, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 144, 12608 (2022).
- S. Li and R. Zandi, Biophysical modeling of SARS-CoV-2 assembly: Genome condensation and budding, Viruses 14, 2089 (2022).
- I. Saha and S. Saffarian, Dynamics of the HIV Gag lattice detected by localization correlation analysis and time-lapse iPALM, Biophys. J. 119, 581 (2020).
- T. Ruiz-Herrero and M. F. Hagan, Simulations show that virus assembly and budding are facilitated by membrane microdomains, Biophys. J. 108, 585 (2015).
- G. S. Ayton and G. A. Voth, Multiscale simulation of protein mediated membrane remodeling, Semin. Cell Dev. Biol. 21, 357 (2010).
- B. Li and S. M. Abel, Shaping membrane vesicles by adsorption of hinge-like nanoparticles, J. Chem. Phys. 160, 194901 (2024).
- W. I. Sundquist and H. G. Krausslich, HIV-1 assembly, budding, and maturation, Cold Spring Harb. Perspect. Med. 2, a006924 (2012).
- M. D. Tomasini, D. S. Johnson, J. S. Mincer, and S. M. Simon, Modeling the dynamics and kinetics of HIV-1 Gag during viral assembly, PLoS One 13, e0196133 (2018).
- C. Floderer, J.-B. Masson, E. Boilley, S. Georgeault, P. Merida, M. El Beheiry, M. Dahan, P. Roingeard, J.-B. Sibarita, C. Favard, and D. Muriaux, Single molecule localisation microscopy reveals how HIV-1 Gag proteins sense membrane virus assembly sites in living host CD4 T cells, Sci. Rep. 8, 16283 (2018).
- Y. Fu and M. E. Johnson, Modeling membrane reshaping driven by dynamic protein assemblies, Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. 78, 102505 (2023).
- Y. Fu, D. H. Johnson, A. H. Beaven, A. J. Sodt, W. F. Zeno, and M. E. Johnson, Predicting protein curvature sorting across membrane compositions, Biophys. J. 125, 1007 (2026).
- W. F. Zeno, U. Baul, W. T. Snead, A. C. M. DeGroot, L. Wang, E. M. Lafer, D. Thirumalai, and J. C. Stachowiak, Synergy between intrinsically disordered domains and structured proteins amplifies membrane curvature sensing, Nat. Commun. 9, 4152 (2018).
- B. R. Capraro, Y. Yoon, W. Cho, and T. Baumgart, Curvature sensing by the epsin N-terminal homology domain measured on cylindrical lipid membrane tethers, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 132, 1200 (2010).
- B. J. Reynwar, G. Illya, V. A. Harmandaris, M. M. Müller, K. Kremer, and M. Deserno, Aggregation and vesiculation of membrane proteins by curvature-mediated interactions, Nature (London) 447, 461 (2007).
- L. Harker-Kirschneck, B. Baum, and A. E. Šarić, Changes in ESCRT-III filament geometry drive membrane remodelling and fission in silico, BMC Biol. 17, 82 (2019).
- L. Harker-Kirschneck, A. E. Hafner, T. Yao, C. Vanhille-Campos, X. Jiang, A. Pulschen, F. Hurtig, D. Hryniuk, S. Culley, R. Henriques, B. Baum, and A. Šarić, Physical mechanisms of ESCRT-III–driven cell division, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 119, e2107763119 (2022).
- L. C. Lin and F. L. Brown, Brownian dynamics in Fourier space: Membrane simulations over long length and time scales, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 256001 (2004).
- S. L. Foley and M. E. Johnson, Hybrid dynamical simulation reveals apparent stiffening of flexible protein lattices driving membrane bending, arXiv:2607.06378.
- B. Li and S. M. Abel, Shaping membrane vesicles by adsorption of a semiflexible polymer, Soft Matter 14, 185 (2018).
- S. Kutti Kandy and R. Radhakrishnan, Crowding-induced membrane remodeling: Interplay of membrane tension, polymer density, architecture, Biophys. J. 121, 3674 (2022).
- H. Ni and G. A. Papoian, Membrane-MEDYAN: Simulating deformable vesicles containing complex cytoskeletal networks, J. Phys. Chem. B 125, 10710 (2021).
- A. Sciortino, H. A. Faizi, D. A. Fedosov, L. Frechette, P. M. Vlahovska, G. Gompper, and A. R. Bausch, Active membrane deformations of a minimal synthetic cell, Nat. Phys. 21, 799 (2025).
- N. Cordella, T. J. Lampo, S. Mehraeen, and A. J. Spakowitz, Membrane fluctuations destabilize clathrin protein lattice order, Biophys. J. 106, 1476 (2014).
- N. Cordella, T. J. Lampo, N. Melosh, and A. J. Spakowitz, Membrane indentation triggers clathrin lattice reorganization and fluidization, Soft Matter 11, 439 (2015).
- M. Giani, W. K. den Otter, and W. J. Briels, Early stages of clathrin aggregation at a membrane in coarse-grained simulations, J. Chem. Phys. 146, 155102 (2017).
- W. Helfrich, Elastic properties of lipid bilayers: Theory and possible experiments, Z. Naturforsch. C 28, 693 (1973).
- E. A. Evans, Bending resistance and chemically induced moments in membrane bilayers, Biophys. J. 14, 923 (1974).
- P. B. Canham, The minimum energy of bending as a possible explanation of the biconcave shape of the human red blood cell, J. Theor. Biol. 26, 61 (1970).
- Y. M. Ying and M. E. Johnson, SLIMED code repository, GitHub, 2026, https://github.com/JohnsonBiophysicsLab/SLIMED.
- G. Niggemann, M. Kummrow, and W. Helfrich, The bending rigidity of phosphatidylcholine bilayers: Dependences on experimental method, sample cell sealing and temperature, J. Phys. II 5, 413 (1995).
- J. R. Henriksen and J. H. Ipsen, Measurement of membrane elasticity by micro-pipette aspiration, Eur. Phys. J. E Soft Matter 14, 149 (2004).
- F. T. Doole, T. Kumarage, R. Ashkar, and M. F. Brown, Cholesterol stiffening of lipid membranes, J. Membr. Biol. 255, 385 (2022).
- D. Dean and M. Manghi, Fluctuation-induced interactions between domains in membranes, Phys. Rev. E 74, 021916 (2006).
- J. Steinkühler, E. Sezgin, I. Urbančič, C. Eggeling, and R. Dimova, Mechanical properties of plasma membrane vesicles correlate with lipid order, viscosity and cell density, Commun. Biol. 2, 337 (2019).
- B. W. Koenig, H. H. Strey, and K. Gawrisch, Membrane lateral compressibility determined by NMR and X-ray diffraction: Effect of acyl chain polyunsaturation, Biophys. J. 73, 1954 (1997).
- W. Rawicz, K. C. Olbrich, T. McIntosh, D. Needham, and E. Evans, Effect of chain length and unsaturation on elasticity of lipid bilayers, Biophys. J. 79, 328 (2000).
- M. Deserno, Fluid lipid membranes: From differential geometry to curvature stresses, Chem. Phys. Lipids. 185, 11 (2015).
- C. Zhu, C. T. Lee, and P. Rangamani, Mem3DG: Modeling membrane mechanochemical dynamics in 3D using discrete differential geometry, Biophys. Rep. 2, 100062 (2022).
- A. L. Le Roux, C. Tozzi, N. Walani, X. Quiroga, D. Zalvidea, X. Trepat, M. Staykova, M. Arroyo, and P. Roca-Cusachs, Dynamic mechanochemical feedback between curved membranes and BAR protein self-organization, Nat. Commun. 12, 6550 (2021).
- C. Tozzi, N. Walani, and M. Arroyo, Out-of-equilibrium mechanochemistry and self-organization of fluid membranes interacting with curved proteins, New J. Phys. 21, 093004 (2019).
- G. Kumar and A. Srivastava, Membrane remodeling due to a mixture of multiple types of curvature proteins, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 18, 5659 (2022).
- A. Ono, S. D. Ablan, S. J. Lockett, K. Nagashima, and E. O. Freed, Phosphatidylinositol (4, 5) bisphosphate regulates HIV-1 Gag targeting to the plasma membrane, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 101, 14889 (2004).
- J. S. Saad, J. Miller, J. Tai, A. Kim, R. H. Ghanam, and M. F. Summers, Structural basis for targeting HIV-1 Gag proteins to the plasma membrane for virus assembly, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 103, 11364 (2006).
- J. Lidmar, L. Mirny, and D. R. Nelson, Virus shapes and buckling transitions in spherical shells, Phys. Rev. E 68, 051910 (2003).
- M. Buenemann and P. Lenz, Mechanical limits of viral capsids, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 104, 9925 (2007).
- See Supplemental Material at http://link.aps.org/supplemental/10.1103/tnv7-fjh5 for Methods, Figures, and Tables (doi: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22307447).
- J. H. Michell, On the direct determination of stress in an elastic solid, with application to the theory of plates, Proc. Lond. Math. Soc. s1-31, 100 (1899).
- T. L. Charles, Smooth subdivision surfaces based on triangles, MS thesis, University of Utah, 1987.
- F. Cirak, M. Ortiz, and P. Schröder, Subdivision surfaces: A new paradigm for thin-shell finite-element analysis, Int. J. Numer. Methods Eng. 47, 2039 (2000).
- X. Wang and G. Danuser, Remeshing flexible membranes under the control of free energy, PLoS Comput. Biol. 18, e1010766 (2022).
- A. Mandal, P. Chaudhuri, and S. Chaudhuri, Real-time physics-based mesh deformation with haptic feedback and material anisotropy, in Proceedings of the 18th International Joint Conference on Computer Vision, Imaging and Computer Graphics Theory and Applications (SCITEPRESS—Science and Technology Publications, Setúbal, Portugal, 2023), pp. 153–161.
- N. C. Gauthier, T. A. Masters, and M. P. Sheetz, Mechanical feedback between membrane tension and dynamics, Trends Cell Biol. 22, 527 (2012).
- Y. Schweitzer, A. D. Lieber, K. Keren, and M. M. Kozlov, Theoretical analysis of membrane tension in moving cells, Biophys. J. 106, 84 (2014).
- A. Pietuch, B. R. Brückner, and A. Janshoff, Membrane tension homeostasis of epithelial cells through surface area regulation in response to osmotic stress, Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1833, 712 (2013).
- P. Wolfe, Convergence conditions for ascent methods, SIAM Rev. 11, 226 (1969).
- D. Frenkel and B. Smit, Understanding Molecular Simulation: From Algorithms to Applications (Academic Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 2001).
- P. Chlanda, E. Mekhedov, H. Waters, A. Sodt, C. Schwartz, V. Nair, P. S. Blank, and J. Zimmerberg, Palmitoylation contributes to membrane curvature in influenza A virus assembly and hemagglutinin-mediated membrane fusion, J. Virol. 91, e00947 (2017).
- N. Kaiser, G. Squires, and T. Broadhurst, A method for weak lensing observations, Astrophys. J. 449, 460 (1995).
- F. W. High, H. Hoekstra, N. Leethochawalit, T. de Haan, L. Abramson, K. A. Aird, R. Armstrong, M. L. N. Ashby, M. Bautz, M. Bayliss, et al., Weak-lensing mass measurements of five galaxy clusters in the south pole telescope survey using magellan/megacam, Astrophys. J. 758, 68 (2012).
- J. A. Anderson, J. Glaser, and S. C. Glotzer, hoomd-blue: A Python package for high-performance molecular dynamics and hard particle Monte Carlo simulations, Comput. Mater. Sci. 173, 109363 (2020).
- github.com/PhysFoley/BrownianProteinFSBDmem.
- N. Bouzos, S. L. Foley, A. Potamianos, C. O. Jacobs, M. E. Johnson, and W. F. Zeno, Clathrin is an intrinsic driver of membrane fission, bioRxiv (2026).
- A. Šarić and A. Cacciuto, Mechanism of membrane tube formation induced by adhesive nanocomponents, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 188101 (2012).
- I. Badvaram and B. A. Camley, Physical limits to membrane curvature sensing by a single protein, Phys. Rev. E 108, 064407 (2023).
- L. Foret, Shape and energy of a membrane bud induced by protein coats or viral protein assembly, Eur. Phys. J. E Soft Matter 37, 42 (2014).
- F. Frey, F. Ziebert, and U. S. Schwarz, Dynamics of particle uptake at cell membranes, Phys. Rev. E 100, 052403 (2019).
- A. Kusumi, C. Nakada, K. Ritchie, K. Murase, K. Suzuki, H. Murakoshi, R. S. Kasai, J. Kondo, and T. Fujiwara, Paradigm shift of the plasma membrane concept from the two-dimensional continuum fluid to the partitioned fluid: High-speed single-molecule tracking of membrane molecules, Annu. Rev. Biophys. Biomol. Struct. 34, 351 (2005).
- R. Dharan, A. Barnoy, A. K. Tsaturyan, A. Grossman, S. Goren, I. Yosibash, D. Nachmias, N. Elia, R. Sorkin, and M. M. Kozlov, Intracellular pressure controls the propagation of tension in crumpled cell membranes, Nat. Commun. 16, 91 (2025).
- S. Aland, A. Rätz, M. Röger, and A. Voigt, Buckling instability of viral capsids—A continuum approach, Multiscale Model. Simul. 10, 82 (2012).
- S. D. Hicks and C. L. Henley, Coarse-grained protein-protein stiffnesses and dynamics from all-atom simulations, Phys. Rev. E 81, 030903 (2010).
- A. J. Bryer, J. S. Rey, and J. R. Perilla, Performance efficient macromolecular mechanics via sub-nanometer shape based coarse graining, Nat. Commun. 14, 2014 (2023).
- A. Deshpande, A. J. Bryer, J. R. Andino-Moncada, J. Shi, J. Hong, C. Torres, S. Harel, A. C. Francis, J. R. Perilla, C. Aiken, and I. Rousso, Elasticity of the HIV-1 core facilitates nuclear entry and infection, PLoS Pathog. 20, e1012537 (2024).