It was suggested some years ago that the reflectivity of He atoms, reflecting from the free surface of liquid He, should show evidence of rotons being created by some of the condensing atoms. However, the measured reflectivity showed no change as the atom energy was scanned through 1.45 K, the energy which is necessary to create a roton of the minimum energy. This was strange as rotons, albeit of higher energy, were detected in the liquid from condensing atoms. We report here clear evidence for the creation of phonons and rotons in the reflectivity data. This enables us to estimate the probabilities for condensing atoms to create ripplons (92%) (upper limit), phonons (1.5%), and rotons (3%), (both lower limits), at an angle of incidence of 83°.