Comment on “Hermitian stochastic methodology for x-ray superfluorescence”
Phys. Rev. A 112, 017701 – Published 25 July, 2025
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/1n7g-rnmy
Abstract
This comment critically examines the paper “Hermitian stochastic methodology for x-ray superfluorescence” by Chuchurka, Sukharnikov, and Rohringer [Phys. Rev. A 109, 063705 (2024)]. The paper proposes a Hermitian framework based on the positive- stochastic equations (PPSEs), claimed to be derived “from first principles,” through a redefinition of physical variables without a clear rationale. However, because the original PPSEs cannot satisfy Hermiticity under any stochastic-diffusion-gauge transformation, the framework necessarily employs representations beyond this gauge freedom, thereby contradicting the original PPSEs and their ensemble-average predictions. The resulting equations have close structural similarities with the previously established Hermitian formalism of stochastic Maxwell-Bloch equations [arXiv:2305.04653 and Phys. Rev. A 110, 023724 (2024)].
